“We are America. Those people are not.”
Those words, spoken at the 1992 Republican National
Convention by its chairman Rich Bond, exemplify the problem we have in this
country — the unwillingness on the part of one side of the political aisle to
grant legitimacy to a view that it doesn’t share.
Of late that’s led to the fight over silent protests by
National Football League players during the playing of “The Star-Spangled
Banner”; and, more recently, reaction to Sunday’s massacre in Las Vegas, most
notably toward those who favor more gun control as being, shall we say, “un-American.”
To me, however, they speak of a form of bullying, in this
case by exclusion. It doesn’t matter if you were born here or have adopted
citizenship — if you don’t believe in our principles you’re not really an
American.
I suggest that it’s bullying because of the focus on power,
specifically the military and the sale of guns.
Concerning the protests against racism in general and police
brutality in particular that caused now-former San Francisco 49ers quarterback
Colin Kaepernick to drop to one knee during the playing of the national anthem
last year, he himself said that it was never a slam against the military — indeed,
his stance was actually recommended by a Green Beret — but that hasn’t stopped
the naysayers from attacking him. Two weeks ago President Trump referred to
protesters as S.O.B.’s, which caused even more players and even some owners to
take a knee. (The owners, some of whom donated to Trump’s presidential
campaign, recognized that the players, over two-thirds of whom are
African-American, are the product.)
And last weekend’s carnage in Las Vegas has put the issue of
gun control front-and-center again. The “patriots” are saying, of course, that
the focus should be on the mental state of the shooter[s], not that he had
weaponry. (Never mind what he actually had; you’d really have to stretch the
Second Amendment to suggest that he had the right to a machine gun.)
It seems to me that the dissent that we say is part and parcel
of American political culture doesn’t always apply. In any nation, let alone
America, politics should lead to compromise for the greater good. But when
there seems to be only one way of “approved” thinking it leads to the kind of
divisiveness we say we don’t want. Because not everyone is going to fall in
line, and if we want a truly united country dissent must be understood,
addressed and honored.
No comments:
Post a Comment